The Paid-in-Full Renewal: How to Turn Balances Into Cash Without Wrecking Your Billing

A single paid-in-full renewal can solve a cash crunch that would otherwise keep you up at night. It is the most reliable cash-flow lever you have — as long as you use it the right way and do not turn it into a habit that hollows out your billing. Let me give you the whole thing: how to price the discount, how to present it the way Jeff Smith does, and how to keep your school healthy while you do it.

The most reliable cash-flow lever you have

I am never a fan of cashing out brand-new enrollments. But going through your billing and finding the people with a three-, four-, or five-year balance who are paying $500, $600, $700, $800 a month, and offering them a paid-in-full renewal — that adds up in a hurry. Pair it with a strong leadership renewal and these become big deals. Jeff Smith and I used to run a contest at our meetings: one school did $27,000 in a single deal, another did $32,000, and we would literally have the live check brought to the meeting, or take a picture of it without the name and routing number, just to anchor in for everyone that it is real.

The reason most schools never hit those numbers is simple: they never asked. If you ask ten people, seven or eight might say no — but one or two say yes, and if you ask enough people, you hit the numbers you need. The same is true of the big co-promotions with local employers. I never had every top employer in town, but I had five of the top ten, and one of them with 45,000 employees in the area just loved the idea. You get some rejection, and you get some enormous wins, but only if you are bold enough to ask and put something in front of them that says what is in it for them.

How much discount? Think time-value-of-money and dropout rate

What I do not want to do is cut off my nose to spite my face. If somebody was going to pay four years in advance and I gave them half off, I would get a cash hit — but I got paid far less than I should for lessons I am most likely going to deliver anyway. So I look at two things.

One is the time value of money. If I would otherwise borrow that money from a credit card at 18 percent, or the bank at 10 percent, or a loan at 7 percent, what is the equivalent of that over seven years? That is the honest cost, with a risk factor built in. Two is my dropout rate. If I am losing only one percent of my students a month, I am not willing to give much of a discount, because the odds they are still here in four or five years are strong. If I am losing seven to ten percent a month, the risk of them being gone in year two is real, so I will give a little more. My rule of thumb is about 25 percent. Jeff Smith runs 20 percent on a four-year renewal, and a little more if the cash is tighter or the dropout is worse. That 20-to-25-percent range on a four-year black belt program is about right.

Present it on a clean sheet — the way Jeff Smith does

Here is the part most owners get wrong: they try to present all the payment options at the moment of the renewal and confuse the buyer. Do not do that. When you renew someone, renew them on the easiest version — monthly. The last thing you want when you are renewing them is to lay out three plans and hear, “Let me go think about that, that’s a lot, I don’t know which one I want.” Ninety percent of the time that is what happens. So renew them on monthly, get them started, and go back later.

Jeff uses a printed sheet — never a scratch pad, because if you start scribbling numbers they think you are making it up. The sheet shows three plans: the monthly, a 90-day plan at five percent off, and paid-in-full at ten percent off. The 90-day plan simply means you take the discount off, divide the balance by four — a fourth down, a fourth at 30 days, a fourth at 60, a fourth at 90 — and on a credit card that stretches to about 120 days.

Then, weeks later — after the student is engaged, getting spotlighted, doing well, maybe just tested and pumped up with a new belt and medals, so the buying temperature is high — Jeff makes small talk (“did we set up your progress check? did you know we’re closed for the Fourth?”) and then: “Oh, by the way, quick question. When we did your black belt renewal, did I go over all the different payment options that could save you up to $3,000, and you could still make monthly payments?” He has it calculated ahead of time, but he never gives an exact number — “up to $3,000,” not “$3,142.98.” Then he pulls the sheet, crosses out the five percent and gives ten on the 90-day, crosses out the ten and gives 20 on the paid-in-full — so now it feels like something special, because he did not go over it at the renewal. No pressure, no “you have to do this today,” because they are already enrolled. It is simply an opportunity to save.

The “decrease your debt” close

When people worry about taking on debt, Jeff has a beautiful reframe. Some pay from savings, some do a HELOC like I recommend, and some put it on a rewards card. But when someone says, “I don’t want to incur any more debt,” he says: “Very smart — nobody wants to do that. That is exactly why this is the best opportunity to decrease your debt, because we are going to take $3,000 off the balance you already owe us. All you are doing is paying your credit card company instead of paying us. You redirect the payment, and you save $3,000. How good is that?” And who actually pays it off in full? Two people: the one who wants to save money, and the one who believes their kid is going all the way to black belt. If there is any doubt in their mind that the kid will drop out, no discount will move them — which is exactly why you build the belief and the engagement first.

Do not live off the fat of the land

Here is the warning, and it is the most important part. Do not run around cashing everybody out and chasing cash deals desperately. Jeff calls it “living off the fat of the land” — you cannot keep doing it without replenishing. Every time you cash out a balance, replace it: enroll someone new or renew someone else so that your monthly billing never goes down. The goal is to build your billing up so that your rent, your payroll, and every other expense are covered the moment billing comes in each month. That is what lets you absorb the surprise $20,000 air-conditioner or the unexpected medical bill without panic. For the crunch-management side of this, see how to cash out balances the smart way, and for the order to renew in, read bottom-up renewals.

And know your healthy target. I want revenue somewhere between 50/50 and 70/30 — that is 50 to 70 percent from up-front cash (down payments, prepaids, paid-in-fulls) and the rest from billing. If 100 percent of your revenue is billing, you are leaving a lot of money on the table. If 90 percent is cash deals, you are living hand-to-mouth in boom-and-bust cycles with no consistent flow to pay the rent. Somewhere in that band is a strong, stable, growing school — and the paid-in-full renewal, used with discipline, is one of the cleanest ways to get there.

About the Author

Stephen Oliver, MBA, 10th Degree Black Belt, founder of Martial Arts Wealth Mastery, is one of the leading coaches in the martial arts industry for developing Million Dollar Martial Arts Schools and helping martial arts schools, BJJ academies, MMA gyms, and combat-sports businesses grow through stronger marketing, enrollment, retention, pricing, and leadership systems.

Free Resources to Grow Your School

Ready to add your next 100 students? Here is how I can help you, starting today:

• Get a FREE copy of Six Simple Steps to Add 100 Students to Your School at FillYourSchool.com.
• Get a FREE copy of Extraordinary Teaching at ExtraordinaryTeaching.com.
• Want a personal game plan? Call our office at 1-720-256-0208 and ask for Bob Dunne to set up a FREE school evaluation with Stephen Oliver.