Why Hiring Fighters as Instructors Backfires: The Floor-Key Standard for Per-Class Staff
Updated
Hiring fighters as per-class instructors backfires because you are paying for a fight record when your school runs on retention. A hired gun teaches what he likes, does not know the families, and misses the student who is drifting. Fix it with a floor key: nobody runs a class until they know the room, teach the card, and attend training.
Watch the original video above. It’s a short clip from a coaching call where a school owner asked me a very practical question about getting his per-class assistants into staff training. My answer went somewhere he didn’t expect, and this article goes further than the clip had time for.
The Question Behind the Question
Here is the situation as it was put to me. The owner runs a school with kids’ classes, an adult MMA class, and an adult Muay Thai class. A few of his staff are salaried. Four others are assistant-level people paid by the class, each picking up six or seven classes a week. He wanted those per-class people in earlier, in staff training, learning the enrollment process and the business side. His question was about compensation: how do you get contract people to show up for training when you only pay them to teach?
That is a fair question, and it is the wrong one to start with. Before I could answer it, I had to know who these people were. And the answer was the one I hear most often from Muay Thai, BJJ, and MMA schools: they were competitors. Highly skilled, externally developed, brought in because of what they could do in the ring or on the mat, and paid by the class because there was something special about them.
Once I knew that, the compensation question took care of itself. The real problem wasn’t how to pay them for training. It was that the arrangement itself told them training was not part of the job.
What a Hired Gun Thinks the Job Is
Picture the job from the hired gun’s side. He comes in two days a week. He teaches a class. He gets paid, often something like $50 an hour, because he is good and you wanted him. Nobody ever said the job was anything other than “come in and teach.” So in his mind, the job is the technique.
That leads to three predictable behaviors, and the owner on the call confirmed every one of them.
He teaches what he wants, not your curriculum
The owner said it better than I could: they tend to teach what they want to teach, putting in their two cents instead of the set curriculum students need for the next level. This is not malice. It’s the natural result of being hired for personal excellence. If you were brought in because of your game, you’ll teach your game. Meanwhile the yellow belt who needs three specific requirements before the next test doesn’t get them, and the progress cycle you built quietly breaks.
He doesn’t know the room
A fighter who comes in for four hours a week does not know names. He doesn’t know which parent is on the fence, which kid missed last week, which adult has a shoulder he babies, or who is two classes away from a stripe. He sees a group to be trained. Your school needs him to see 25 separate relationships that each have to be kept.
He doesn’t see the drift
Retention is mostly noticing. The student who used to come three times a week and now comes once. The kid who stopped making eye contact. The parent who now waits in the car. A per-class instructor who walks in at 5:58 and leaves at 7:02 will not notice any of it. He isn’t running the character development worksheets. He isn’t keeping anyone on cycle for progress. He isn’t flagging absences. Those things were never in his job, so they don’t happen.
None of this makes him a bad person or a bad martial artist. It makes him the wrong thing to put in charge of your students’ experience.
Champions Aren’t the Problem. Part-Time Outsiders Are.
I want to be careful here, because this is not an argument against champions.
In the 1970s, the Jhoon Rhee Institute in Washington, D.C., where I later served as a head instructor and branch manager while at Georgetown, was staffed with a stable of professional kickboxers. Grand Master Jeff Smith was the world light heavyweight champion, and in four of the five weight classes of that era the Institute had either a world champion or the top U.S. contender on staff. That was one of the strongest staffs the industry has ever seen.
The difference was that they were full-time staff inside one system. They taught the Jhoon Rhee curriculum, not their personal favorites. They knew the students. They were trained, managed, and held to a teaching standard every day. Their fight records were a bonus on top of the job, not a replacement for it.
So the distinction I care about isn’t fighter versus non-fighter. It’s two other distinctions:
- Developed inside versus brought in from outside. Someone who came up through your leadership program already knows your curriculum, your language, and your families. An outsider knows none of it.
- Full-time versus a few hours a week. A full-timer can be trained, coached, and held accountable. Someone you see for four hours a week mostly can’t.
A hired gun is usually on the wrong side of both. That’s why it backfires. I put very little premium on a competitive record and a very high premium on teaching ability.
The Real Cost of a Hired Gun
Let’s put numbers on it, because owners tend to see the $50 an hour and miss the much bigger figure hiding behind it.
Take one youth class with 25 students at a premium tuition of $375 a month. That class carries $9,375 a month, or $112,500 a year. The instructor running it is managing a six-figure book of business, whether anyone told him that or not.
Now compare two versions of that class:
- A well-coached class running under 2% monthly attrition loses about one student every other month, or around six a year.
- A class run at the industry’s typical 3–5% attrition, say 4%, loses about one student a month, or around twelve a year.
That’s six extra students a year leaving one class. If each of them would have stayed even twelve more months at $375, that’s $27,000 in lost tuition from one class in one year. Then you have to replace them, and a new student costs five to seven times more to acquire than to keep, roughly $150 to $300 each in ad spend and staff time before they ever step on the mat.
Meanwhile, the hired gun who seemed expensive costs you $50 a class, seven classes a week, about $18,200 a year. His pay isn’t the expensive part. The students who leave on his watch are. When you look at it that way, it makes no sense to hand a $112,500 class to someone whose only qualification is a fight record.
The Floor-Key Standard
The fix isn’t a lecture and it isn’t a pay raise. It’s a standard. I call it the Floor-Key Standard, and the idea is simple: being allowed to run or assist a class is a key that has to be earned, one class at a time, and kept by meeting the standard. Nobody gets on the floor because of who they are. They get on the floor because they’ve shown they can take care of the people in that room.
The standard has five parts:
- The Roster Key: know every student and family in the class.
- The Card Lock: teach the curriculum from the lesson card.
- The Paid Huddle: re-write the per-class pay so it covers the huddle and the training.
- The 60-Day Sort: convert, reassign, or release.
- The Inside Bench: build your next instructors from your own students.
Part One: The Roster Key
Here’s the standard I gave on the call. Only people who know all the names are ever allowed on the floor. If I’m letting someone touch a kids’ class, I want them to know the kids, the parents, and the grandparents when the grandparents come in. I want them to know each child’s track record, history, and next step.
That sounds like a nice idea until you turn it into a test. Then it becomes something you can actually enforce.
How to run the roster check
For each class an instructor wants to run, sit down with him and the class roster for ten minutes. Cover the names and ask, student by student:
- What is this student’s name, and what do they like to be called?
- Who brings them? What are the parents’ names?
- What rank are they, and what’s their next stripe or test?
- When did they last attend, and how often do they usually come?
- Is anyone in this class missing or drifting right now?
The passing standard is high on purpose: every name, and most of the rest. An instructor who can’t name the students in the class he’s teaching doesn’t have the key to that class yet. He can assist under someone who does until he earns it.
Keep the key current
A key isn’t permanent. Rosters change every month. Re-check each instructor on each class about once a month, and whenever a new group of students joins. It takes ten minutes, and it tells you more about how an instructor is doing than any amount of watching him teach technique.
Why this works on fighters
Competitors respect standards. They’ve spent years being measured. A clear test with a clear pass line speaks their language far better than “be more engaged with the students.” You’re not asking for a vague change in attitude. You’re asking them to pass something, and most of them will want to.
Part Two: The Card Lock
The second complaint on the call was the curriculum drift. The fix is to make the curriculum physical.
Teach from the card
Every class runs from a lesson card: warm-up, the requirements being worked that week for each rank in the room, a drill, the character lesson, and the close. The card is set before the class, not invented at the door. The instructor’s job is to deliver it well. If he wants to change something, he raises it in the huddle, not in the middle of class.
Give his expertise one slot
Here’s the part that keeps good fighters from feeling caged. Their experience is valuable. A Muay Thai competitor really does know things about clinch work or ring craft that your students would love. So give that knowledge a home: one scheduled slot, maybe five minutes at the end of class once a week, or a monthly guest workshop. His personal material gets a stage. It just doesn’t get to replace the curriculum your students need to progress.
That trade matters. You aren’t telling him his game is worthless. You’re telling him it has a place, and the place isn’t the whole class.
Spot-check the card
Once a week, pick one class per instructor and compare what was taught to what was on the card. If the class doesn’t match the card two weeks in a row, that’s a conversation, not a shrug. Students pay $375 a month for a path to black belt. The card is that path, one class at a time.
Part Three: The Paid Huddle
Now back to the owner’s original question: how do you get per-class people into training?
You stop treating training as an extra you have to bribe them into. Today his deal says, in effect, “I pay you to teach a class.” That makes every minute outside class feel like unpaid overtime. So rewrite the deal.
Redefine what the class rate buys
The new arrangement says the per-class rate covers three things:
- The pre-class huddle. Fifteen minutes before the class: today’s card, who’s coming back from an absence, who’s close to a stripe, any parent who needs a word.
- The class itself. Taught from the card, to the roster standard.
- The post-class two minutes. Write down who was missing, who struggled, and who needs a call.
On top of that, holding a floor key requires attending the monthly staff training. That’s not something you pay extra for. It’s a condition of having the key, the same way a black belt candidate has to attend the required classes. If someone wants to run classes in your school, this is what running a class means here.
You can raise the rate a little when you do this, and you probably should if the new definition takes meaningfully more of their time. But the important change is the definition, not the number. You’re no longer paying for an appearance. You’re paying for a professional who takes care of a room full of students.
Set the rule before the conversation
Have this conversation once, clearly, with all of them at the same time, with the new expectations in writing. Give a start date. Don’t negotiate it person by person, or you’ll end up with four different deals and resentment between them.
Part Four: The 60-Day Sort
Some hired guns will love this. They’ve been waiting for someone to show them how to be more than a technician. Others will hate it. Give everyone 60 days under the new standard, then sort them into one of three groups.
Convert
He passes the roster check on his classes, teaches the card, shows up to the huddles and the training, and his classes are holding their students. He’s now staff. Bring him into the leadership side of your school, start teaching him how enrollment and progress conferences work, and treat him as a future team member. This is the person the owner on the call was hoping to build in the first place.
Reassign
He’s a gifted athlete and a real asset, but he won’t or can’t take care of a room. Don’t put him in charge of a class. Use him where his skill is the point: guest workshops, seminar days, a monthly advanced session for upper ranks, or coaching your competitors. Pay him for those events. Take his name off the regular schedule.
Release
He won’t meet the standard and won’t accept a reassignment. Thank him, pay him what he’s owed, and let him go cleanly. Then watch that class closely for the next month, because some students will feel the change. Have your strongest instructor teach it, call every family in the class, and keep the routine steady.
The worst choice is the one most owners make: they keep the hired gun on the schedule, privately unhappy with him, because they’re afraid to lose his skill. Meanwhile his classes keep leaking students at 4% a month.
Part Five: The Inside Bench
The floor key fixes the staff you have. The long-term fix is to stop needing hired guns at all.
My strong preference, which I’ve followed for decades, is that everyone on my floor is developed inside the school. They come up through the leadership program. They learn to teach and lead as part of their own training. By the time they get paid, they already know the curriculum, the families, and the culture, because they grew up in it.
Who gets paid
The people I end up putting on payroll through that path are usually high school and college students. The reason is simple: I don’t want them to have to choose between helping in my school and taking tickets at the movie theater or asking “do you want fries with that?” across a counter. Paying them keeps them on my floor during the years when they’re becoming excellent.
Who stays volunteer
The adults are different. Over the years I’ve had hundreds of adults, from 35-year-old engineers to 55-year-old surgeons, who spend 10 or 12 hours a week helping in the school and never go on payroll. They don’t want an hourly wage. They want to belong, to grow, and to give back. So we take care of them: a staff jacket with their name on it, an evening out with the team, being thanked in front of the room. Hourly pay would actually make that relationship worse.
What the inside bench gives you
Every person on that bench already holds a floor key before you need them, because they’ve been in those classes for years. They know the names because those students are their friends’ kids and their training partners. They teach the curriculum because it’s the curriculum that made them. And they come to training because training has always been part of their path. The inside bench solves the hired-gun problem without any special arrangements.
Putting the Floor-Key Standard to Work This Month
Here’s how to roll it out without upsetting your schedule.
- Week one: List every class and who runs or assists it. Mark each person as developed inside or brought in from outside, and as full-time or part-time.
- Week one: Write the lesson card format and a card for each class for the next four weeks.
- Week two: Meet with all per-class staff together. Explain the floor key, the card lock, the paid huddle, and the monthly training. Give a start date and put it in writing.
- Week three: Run the first roster check for every instructor on every class. Anyone who doesn’t pass assists under someone who does and gets re-checked in two weeks.
- Weeks three through ten: Hold the huddles, spot-check the cards, and track attendance and drops class by class.
- Day 60: Sort everyone into convert, reassign, or release, and act on it.
- Ongoing: Grow the inside bench through your leadership program, so next year you’re promoting from within instead of hiring from outside.
Watch two numbers by class through the whole process: monthly attrition and the share of students on pace for their next rank. If the standard is working, both move in the right direction within a quarter.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I stop hiring competitive fighters as instructors?
No. Stop hiring them for the wrong reason. A fight record is fine as a bonus, but it’s not a qualification for running a class. Judge every instructor, fighter or not, on whether they can earn and keep the floor key: know the room, teach the curriculum, and take part in training. Fighters who do that can be excellent staff.
How do I get per-class instructors to attend staff training without paying them extra?
Redefine what the class rate covers. Make the pre-class huddle, the post-class notes, and monthly training part of what it means to hold a class in your school, put it in writing, and introduce it to everyone at once. You can raise the rate modestly if the time commitment grows, but training is a condition of the job, not an extra.
Should adult volunteers who help in my school be paid?
Usually not. In my experience, adults who give 10 to 12 hours a week are motivated by belonging and growth, not wages. Recognize them with a staff jacket, team outings, and public thanks. Paid roles work best for high school and college students, so they don’t have to choose between your school and a part-time job elsewhere.
Your Next Step
The Floor-Key Standard is one of the staff systems we install with owners in the Staff and Leadership hub, where you’ll find more on building instructors from inside your school. Because every class you hand over affects whether students stay, see the Retention hub for how to keep attrition under 2% a month. And when you’re ready to grow beyond one owner on one floor, the School Growth hub shows how staffing and growth fit together.
If you have per-class instructors on your schedule right now and aren’t sure which of them to convert, reassign, or release, book your free Personal Evaluation, a $1,297 value. We’ll look at your staff and your class-by-class numbers with you and help you decide what to change first.
And because every instructor on your floor has to teach your program to your standard, get the free Extraordinary Teaching resource at ExtraordinaryTeaching.com.
Your School Should Not Depend on You Doing Everything
In your free growth diagnostic, Stephen Oliver and Jeff Smith will identify the biggest obstacle between your school or gym and its next revenue level — and map the most direct path forward. A $1,297 value, at no charge and no obligation.
About the Author
Stephen Oliver, MBA and 10th Degree Black Belt, is the Founder and CEO of Mile High Karate and Martial Arts Wealth Mastery, CEO of NAPMA (National Association of Professional Martial Artists), and Publisher of Martial Arts Professional magazine. A martial arts school owner since 1975, he and his coaching team — including Grand Master Jeff Smith and Dr. Greg Moody — have helped school owners across the world build $1M+ schools.


Schedule Your Free Business Evaluation and receive FREE Bonuses. Call or Text now: