Stop Switching Suppliers: The 90 Percent Vendor Rule
Updated
A martial arts school should keep any supplier or agency that does the job well 80 to 90 percent of the time, and stop switching to save small amounts. Perfection does not exist in this industry. Every switch costs owner time, adds risk and breaks a working system. Judge a vendor by its total effect on enrollment and by the hours it saves you, not by the line-item price. The owner’s job is to fill the school, not to trim pennies.
Why do so many school owners keep switching suppliers?
Because they expect perfection, and when a vendor misses once they go shopping. I keep talking to owners who changed their uniform or belt supplier after one back-order, or who call around every month to see whether somebody will knock a dime off a belt.
I never expected perfection, because there is no such thing. I expected a supplier to do what they said 80 to 90 percent of the time, to the point that I thought they were the best choice. Given some recent events in the industry, it is worth rethinking how you deal with suppliers. The answer is good relationships, not constant shopping.
What does a good vendor relationship look like?
When I ran a large tournament, some years we spent around $50,000 on trophies. What I wanted was the guy who would drive his van across the country, show up with everything, set it up, and be good enough that nobody complained.
We used the same supplier most of those years. He drove in from Missouri, set up the awards, tore down whatever was left, and gave us credit for the stock he could reuse. Some years I worried he would not make it on time because of a blizzard in Kansas. A couple of times the engraving was not perfect.
The last thing I was going to do was change, because he was good 95 percent of the time. The next guy was an unknown. You do not want 1,300 competitors to show up one morning and find that the trophies did not.
Meanwhile I watched other promoters running smaller events get upset because a plate was slightly off, and switch suppliers over it. They traded a known, reliable partner for a gamble.
Is saving 20 cents a belt worth it?
No. Here is how my equipment ordering worked: I could call on Monday, they would drop-ship, and I would have the order. I could call on Friday and have it on Monday. Their prices were within about 10 percent of anybody’s, and their quality was within 10 or 20 percent of anybody’s. I had a system, so I never had to think about it.
Now someone tells you another company has a special and you can save 20 cents apiece on green belts. Do the math on the brain damage. You change ordering systems, learn a new catalog, deal with a new shipping schedule and risk a short shipment before a belt graduation, all to save a few dollars a month.
How should you judge a marketing agency?
By what happens to the whole school, not by the cost per lead on its report. Everything in your marketing interacts. Ads on social media drive people to search for you, so a share of the leads from a good agency show up as website leads, not ad leads.
Years ago I hated Yellow Pages advertising and was still spending around $50,000 a year on it. I had to, because we ran a lot of television, and when you run 30-second spots nobody writes your number down. They went to the phone book. If I had pulled the Yellow Pages ad, my TV would have generated calls for other schools.
The same thing happens today. One member canceled an ad agency and watched website leads fall off at the same time, even though the school had increased its live events that month. The agency was producing more than its own report showed.
So when you compare a cheaper option with the one you have:
- Measure everything that moved: ad leads, website leads, phone calls and appointments, not just the ad platform’s numbers.
- If the cheaper option produces comparable results on both the ads and the website, switch and keep the savings.
- If it produces worse results, ask how much worse and how much money that costs you each month in lost enrollments.
- If it is only slightly better or worse, weigh the time and disruption of switching again.
Do not ask what the cheapest way is to get a lead from Meta. Ask how to maximize your overall results.
Should you run your own ads to save the agency fee?
Maybe, but count your hours. Before we settled on an agency, we had used seven others. Most were good for about six weeks and then faded. The one we kept was consistently good about nine months out of twelve. That means it had some bad months and dropped the ball now and then. It was still the best we found.
Could I beat them doing it myself? I did it myself for a couple of years, and I probably could. But I would be beating them with about ten hours of my time every month. That was not worth it to save the fee.
The same logic runs through the rest of the business. I could do better bookkeeping than the bookkeeper my accountant uses. I do not want to spend a thousand-dollar hour doing fifty-dollar work. I could weed-whack five acres myself in about four days. A crew with riding mowers does it in three hours, and I have a better use of my time.
Why do growing schools keep thinking like small ones?
I regularly see owners who used to run a $10,000-a-month school and now run an $80,000 or $120,000-a-month school, still thinking like the broke guy trying to trim everything. The reason the broke guy is broke is that he is trying to trim every penny rather than add 100 new students.
If he stopped changing his own oil, mowing his own lawn and negotiating belt prices, and went out and filled the place up, he would have cash flow. Your highest-value work is enrollment, retention and leadership. Pick good vendors, hold them to a realistic standard and give that time back to the floor.
Key takeaways
- Set a realistic bar: a vendor who delivers 80 to 90 percent of the time is a keeper.
- Count the cost of switching in owner hours and risk, not just price.
- Judge agencies by total school results, including website leads and calls.
- Do not trade ten hours a month of your time to save a modest fee.
- Spend your energy adding students, not trimming pennies.
To find where your own time is best spent, book the Most Valuable Hour.
Frequently asked questions
How often should a martial arts school change suppliers?
Rarely. If a supplier delivers reliably 80 to 90 percent of the time at a price close to the market, the savings from switching are usually smaller than the time and risk involved.
How do I know if my marketing agency is actually working?
Track total leads from every source, including website leads and calls, along with appointments and enrollments. Ads often drive people to search for you, so the agency’s own report can understate its effect.
Should a school owner manage Facebook ads personally?
Only if the hours are worth it. An owner might match an agency’s results, but if it takes about ten hours a month, that time is usually better spent on enrollment and staff.
What is a realistic standard for a vendor?
Expect the vendor to do what it promised most of the time, roughly 80 to 90 percent, with honest communication when it misses. Expecting perfection leads to constant switching.



Schedule Your Free Business Evaluation and receive FREE Bonuses. Call or Text now:

